• About
  • Contact
  • Work with me
  • As Seen In

84th&3rd

Unprocessed allergy-friendly recipes

84thand3rd
  • Food
    • *THAT* Chocolate Cake
    • Recipes
    • Dining Out
  • Travel
  • Life
« Roasted Pear, Parmesan & Spiced Pecan Salad
Taste of Sydney 2014 and IconPark »

Buttermilk Pumpkin Pie for Pi Day

March 14, 2014 By JJ 3 Comments

Buttermilk Pumpkin Custard Pie

Happy Pi Day!

That’s right, not Pie Day — that one falls on 23 January each year as declared by The American Pie Council, “the only organisation committed to preserving America’s pie heritage … [to] raise awareness, enjoyment and consumption of pies”.

But Pi Day — derived from the date matching the first three digits of Pi, an infinite non-repeating pattern created by the ratio of a circle’s circumference to its diameter aka 3.14159265359andonandonitgoes.

Buttermilk Pumpkin Custard Pie

Apparently Pi Day was created “to convince the world that mathematics is fun” — and was even made an official day in 2009 by an United States House of Representatives resolution — but it doesn’t take a 60,00-digits-of-Pi-genius to work out that eating pie on Pi day is far more party-friendly than yelling numbers at a wall.

So on to pie. Pie dreamt up to use up a jar in my fridge filled with the liquid left over after making butter — ie buttermilk, yes really. Pie created without a crust because even though I’ve been on a mission to create brilliant pie crusts I still like the filling best. Pie that while pictured in lovely civilised slices was in reality eaten with a spoon straight from the pan, not that there’s anything wrong with that.

Buttermilk Pumpkin Custard Pie

On to the recipe in just a moment but first a selection of facts* about pie from the American Pie Council:

  • Nearly one out of five (19%) of Americans prefer apple pie, followed by pumpkin (13%), pecan (12%), banana cream (10%) and cherry (9%).
  • Over a third (35%) of Americans say they’ve had pies for breakfast. Pies as lunch (66%) and midnight snacks (59%) also have a popular following.
  • When asked what dessert Americans would prefer a friend or family member bring to their house for a holiday dinner, pie was the winner (29%). Cake (17%) and cookies (15%) rounded out the top-three spots.
  • Pie was not always America’s favourite dessert — in the 19th Century, fruit pies were a common breakfast food eaten before the start of a long day.

Looks like research has now justified my penchant for pie for breakfast. Everybody wins.

Oh one final note — next year on March 14, 2015 at 9:26 and 53 seconds, during a brief moment just after your slice of breakfast pie, the date and time will perfectly match the first ten digits of Pi: 3.141592653. If the world doesn’t end we should all celebrate with more pie. 

Buttermilk Pumpkin Custard Pie

Buttermilk Pumpkin Custard Pie

Creamy and smooth and just a little bit spiced, this pie is perfect with or without a crust and ideal for any time of day — breakfast and midnight snacks included.

Makes one 8 inch pie tin of filling

INGREDIENTS

  • 1 c roasted pureed pumpkin (or the canned stuff if you must)
  • 1 c buttermilk
  • 2 eggs
  • 1 tsp vanilla bean paste or extract
  • 1 Tbsp butter, melted
  • ¼ c rice syrup
  • 1 tsp cinnamon
  • ¼ tsp each ginger, clove & allspice powders
  • pinch each sea salt & nutmeg

METHOD

Preheat oven to 180°C (350°F). Lightly brush a pie pan with a bit of the melted butter, reserving remaining for filling.

Whisk together all ingredients and pour into prepared pan.

Bake approximately 30 mins until edges are golden and centre is just wobbly. Recite Pi while waiting for the pie to cool on a rack.

COOK’S NOTES

  • Buttermilk: if you make your own butter from fresh cream instead of cultured cream you’ll want to add a tsp of lemon juice to the buttermilk because it will be sweet.
  • Non-Dairy: yes, you can replace the buttermilk with non-dairy milk mixed with a tsp of lemon juice and replace the butter with your non-dairy butter substitute.
  • Syrup: feel free to replace rice syrup with maple or honey and adjust the quantity to taste.
  • Baking: the pie is done when the tip of a knife inserted halfway from edge to centre comes out clean.

vegetarian // gluten-free // soy-free // refined sugar-free // dairy-free option

*Pie Fun Facts from a 2008 survey by Crisco and American Pie Council because someone actually commissioned research research about this stuff (fyi, laughing hysterically as I type this, knowing that while it was probably part of a marketing campaign by the brand sponsor I still find it both completely ludicrous and so very brilliant). 

Related Posts

Apple & Cinnamon Breakfast Cookies {GF, DF}

Apple & Cinnamon Breakfast Cookies {GF, DF}

Corn, Zucchini & Saltbush Fritters

Corn, Zucchini & Saltbush Fritters

Pumpkin Spice Cake for Australia's Biggest Morning Tea

Pumpkin Spice Cake for Australia's Biggest Morning Tea

Pear Upside-Down Cake

Pear Upside-Down Cake

Filed Under: All Posts, Events, Food, RecipeBox Tagged With: Autumn, Breakfast, Dairy Free, Deliciousness, Dessert, Had-to-share, Holidays, Pie!, Pumpkin, Treats, Veggie Cakes

Comments

  1. Joanne T Ferguson says

    March 14, 2014 at 4:22 pm

    G’day! Happy Pi Day to you JJ!
    Enjoyed your post, recipe and photo and sharing the love today!
    Cheers! Joanne

    Reply
  2. brenda hayes says

    March 15, 2014 at 5:44 am

    Makes me hungry.

    Reply

Trackbacks

  1. Buttermilk Pumpkin Custard Pie Recipe - RecipeChart.com says:
    March 22, 2014 at 11:11 pm

    […] Full Recipe Link: http://84thand3rd.com/2014/03/14/buttermilk-pumpkin-pie-for-pi-day/ […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get social

84th-instagram 84th-heart 84th-facebook 84th-youtube
84th-twitter 84th-pinterest 84th-gplus 84th-star

Subscribe

New posts, straight to your inbox, simple as that.

Browse by…

Almost Recipe America-land Autumn BlogHop Boozer Bread Breakfast Brunch Cake! Chocolate Christmas Christmas Recipes Coconut Cookbook Cookies Dairy Free Deliciousness Dessert Dinner Family Fruit Gluten Free Had-to-share Holidays Ingredient Focus Inspiration Lunch Mad Science Nuts On-blogging Photo-A-Day Pie! Probably Paleo Refined Sugar Free Sauces Sides Snacks Stuff-n-Things Summer Sydney Thanksgiving / Christmas Treats Vegan Vegetarian Winter

@84thand3rd on Instagram

Cheers to the long weekend. . . . Had a bit of a Cheers to the long weekend. 
.
.
.
Had a bit of a play a week (or five) ago. Used what was on hand, and chased limited time. Drank it when I was done.
.
Local CA gin, Italian aperitif wine, punchy sparkling water, blood orange. Single bare strobe. That’ll do.
Felt cute, might delete later. Insert quote about Felt cute, might delete later. Insert quote about cracks being how the light gets in ✨. 
.
.
.
.
Hollywood, CA. May, 2023.
TGIF y’all. ••• The quail egg mini brunch TGIF y’all. 
•••
The quail egg mini brunch spread is back. This time in all its stop motion glory. Go forth and brunch thyself (waffle thyself? coffee thyself? dealers choice). 💥🍳🧇🍞🥑☕️🫖
.
.
.
.
.
#stopmotionanimation #stopmotionvideo #tabletopphotography #thenwebrunch #whatsforbreakfast #beautifulcuisines #foodandwine #thekitchn #f52grams
Apertivo debris. 🥃🧀🫒 • That’s it. Tha Apertivo debris. 🥃🧀🫒
•
That’s it. That’s the post.
Apparently today is National Strawberry Day, it’ Apparently today is National Strawberry Day, it’s overcast and raining in LA (so a plate of sunshine is absolutely necessary), and if you’ve been here for more than a hot second you know how I feel about toast.
🍞🍓🥒🌱
Toasted sourdough, goat chèvre (or vegan cream cheese), sliced strawberries, cucumber ribbons, fresh mint, olive oil, black pepper, just a pinch of salt. Go forth and feast.
.
.
.
.
.
#f52grams #f52community #whatsforbreakfast #eatrealfood #stuffontoast #nationalstrawberryday #lifeandthyme #eeeeeats #beautifulfood #foodandwine
I took this video on Jan 1. I even wrote a caption I took this video on Jan 1. I even wrote a caption and everything. And I intended to post it that day as a reflection moving into a new year. But instead, mom and I went out for pizza and wine, and then it was Jan 2, and so on and so on. 
🌀
So instead you’re getting it on Feb 1. A new day and another new month (but what is a new month or a new year, other than a societal convention really). 
☀️
Because, each day, each sunrise, we have the opportunity to start anew - no matter how big or little that start may be. A chance to take another step forward - no matter how many steps back you feel you’re fighting against. 
🌀
Whether this past year brought blinding joy or paralysing grief (and in whatever measure of balance or imbalance), I hope each new day sees the landscape of your life look one step closer to what you imagine it to be. And that when the waves roll in and change that landscape, you can roll with it and see the beauty and possibility on the other side.
🌊
If you’ve made it this far, congratulations, have a cookie 🍪 And I’ll leave you with the rolling waves and blue sky of a California beach in January. I truly hope this year sees us all grow stronger and move forward with each new day. Going backwards is simply not an option. 
🪩
What’s your order? 🍳 … When the middle litt What’s your order? 🍳
…
When the middle little insisted on buying quail eggs over Christmas, but due to allll the other food we never cooked them, I simply couldn’t let the little guys go to waste. 
🥚
Could I have made one dish? Of course. Did I instead prepare quail eggs four ways, bake mini loaves of brioche, make mini waffles, dig through the prop closet for the smallest dishes, and set up an entire table? Of course I did. 
💥
Swipe to the end for reference on the size of the eggs and loaf.
🌀
Prep, styling, 📷 & 👋🏻 by me 💁🏼‍♀️.
.
.
.
.
#whatsforbreakfast #beautifulcuisines #eggsforbreakfast #lifeandthyme #foodandwine #foodartproject
Happy Blursday. ☕️ ••• Styled & poured b Happy Blursday. ☕️
•••
Styled & poured by me 💁🏼‍♀️, photographed & lit by @ivansocal 📷, at @plateandpatina 🍽
•••
Pour-over vessel is a @decadentpantry test piece that came with me from Sydney. That’s it, I got nothing else. Send kittens.
.
.
.
#stopmotionanimation #stopmotion #manmakecoffee #pourovercoffee #pourover #coffeecoffeecoffee
My go-to pizza topping combo 🍕 Made on that dou My go-to pizza topping combo 🍕 Made on that dough from a couple weeks ago and voiced by the middle little (who is about as different from her younger sister as you can get!) 💥.
🍕
Sometimes this combo gets prawns too 🍤. Most of the time I don’t bother mixing the ingredients in a bowl and just layer them on top. The cheese is a hard goat cheese (because I can’t do 🐄). The ‘spices’ 🌱 is Sicilian oregano. The measurements are random at best - a handful of this, a splash of that. 
🍕
If you have a fave veggie or seafood pizza combo I’d love to hear it. Because as Ms.S says, voila, yummy yummy pizza!
Load More Follow on Instagram

Visit JJ’s Portfolio

Jennifer Jenner Portfolio

Be nice, don’t steal

All work on 84thand3rd.com is the property of the site owner unless otherwise credited. Recipes and articles are NOT available for syndication or re-publication. A single watermarked photo can be used in recipe wrap-up articles to link back to the original recipe post on this site. Photos are available to purchase for other uses.

© All Rights Reserved

Want to use something? Contact me and ask.

instagram heart facebook twitter YouTube pinterest tumblr star gplus

Copyright © 2025 · 84th & 3rd